Like many other fields, disagreements within its own inner circles occur in defining the limits of Astrology.
However, with Astrology's controversy and public scrutiny; It becomes increasingly more important as astrologers to
be relaying a consistent message to the general public.
Some questions which never have been agreed upon in Astrology include :
1) Fate Versus Free-Will : Traditional astrologers lean towards viewing reality in a
fatalistic manner. While Modern Humanistic
Astrologers believed the future can be altered.
2) How Astrology Works : What is it that makes Astrology possible? Is it the physical vibrational forces
that the planets emanate travelling onto the earth such as the law of
gravity?
Or the using the theory of
Synchronicity as suggested
by Carl Jung.
3) Predictive outcomes : While their are rules which are fairly universal in Astrology. Such as the the
nature of Venus is opposite of that from Mars. Astrologers cannot agree upon the predictive outcome of the matter.
As two different astrologers viewing a clients transit may have different intepretations of the planetery energy.
While they may agree upon the general nature of the transit. The exact outcome of how it plays it in the clients
life may be drastically different.
Part of the reason for these agreements is the inability to sufficiently test different theories. As their
currently is not enough in the way of Astrological research to iron out the fine details.
Yet their is a scientific field which stands close to Astrology. With scientist who are working dilligently to
determine the nature of reality. This field is known as Quantum Mechanics. Which to date has been the closest
possibility to describe that Astrology scientifically
CAN work
In a nutshell,
Quantum physics is the study of the interconnectedness of matter when viewed on the
sub-atomic level. The result of Quantum Mechanics findings have revolutionized our way of thinking. And destroyed
our conceptions and theories of the nature of reality built over the last few centuries. Representing a hubris for
some in the scientific community. As it re-united science with spirit, albeit in different form. Where it once
dissected in the age of
enlightenment. In the effort to
seperate from the empire of church, moving science away from all ideas with religious suggestion
Examples of ideas that came in conflict include :
1) The earth and the planets revolves around the Sun : Challenging the Christian ideal that
the Sun and the Planets revolve around the Earth.
2) Darwinism and the Theory of Evolution : Contradicting the idea that
man was created in the likeness of god.
3) The big bang theory : Versus the idea that
God created the universe in 7 days.
However the greatest impact occurred in the age of enlightenment that the universe was understandable and
comphrehensible. Via through the understanding of mechanical laws. These laws include that of Newtonian physics,
mathematics, chemistry to name a few. Therefore mastery of the laws of nature would lead to absolute understanding
of the universe. Which created the mission science in the following centuries. With the resultant of revolutionary
changes in technology, health and our lifestyle.
Yet Quantum Physics has discovered the laws of nature are not absolute. Only from our perspective do these laws
exist.
PRINCIPAL OF UNCERTAINTY - FATE VS FREEWILL
One of the key concepts of Quantum Mechanics is the principal of uncertainty. This has best been demonstrated in
the double slit experiment initially conducted by phycisist Thomas Young.
What the Bleep do we Know - Double Slit
Experiment
The double slit experiment demonstrated that
MIND does in fact influence manner. As particles had no
physical connection to the observer change their behaviour while being observed. Moving through one particular slit
when monitored in that region. And through and opposing slit when conversly watched.
Though the scope of the double experiment was small. It implied a great deal which served to contradict our picture
of reality. Some these challenges include
1)Objective universe : Absolute reality
did not exist.
Thoughts are things and effect matter
without any direct
cause and effect relationship
2)Connectiveness : We are connected to the universe. Despite not being an visible any connection. Our
influence extends beyond our body
3)Consistency : From the viewpoint of
newtonian physics the laws of science should be
consistent 100% of the time. If they are not there is another law to explain it's opposing behaviour. Similar to
the law of
interia for a moving object.
While these question pose a challenge for all of us in the way we look at life. In reference to Astrology they
relate in the given framework
1)Objective universe : What we
BELIEVE to be the outcome of a prediction has an effect on the
actual outcome.
2)Connectiveness : >This principal helps to support Astrology through the theory of entanglement. As one
of the fundamental hurdles of skeptism of Astrology is believing that we are connected to something outside
ourself.
3)Consistency : We can understand all the laws of Astrology. Precisely understand their mathematical
motions. But even with an idealistic mastery of how planetary forces interact with each other. 100% certainty is
not a possible.
omac
Yet Quantum Physics has shown these laws are not as
Science had disconnected from Spirit. And sought to explain everything in mechanical laws. Therefore the laws of
classical Newtonian physics, implied that theoritically all the physical laws we're understood. Then nature could be
manipulated, predicted and understood. Seperating any notions or idea that are no followed without reason or proof.
As there was no proof to support that we are seperated from the universe aside from our physical body.
The advancements and technology of today has demonstrated our proficiency in understanding the mechanical laws. What
would have been considered sorcery at one time, as commonplace. Inventions such as the lightbulb, the automobile,
the Internet would have blown the mind of the medieval man. As it would be considered from the lack of understanding
of the mechanical laws that they we're created by magic.
However, we have now probed so deeply into the nature of reality. It only APPEARS that the mechanical laws are
absolute, fixed and constant throughout the universe. As studying matter on a sub-atomic level. Quantum physicist
have found a number of startingly reality. Some of them include
1) Although particles across the universe may not be connected. They can resonate with each other and respond
instantaneously (Faster than the speed of light, indicating they are not communicating through matter)
2) Although particles appear to be in one place (Entanglement). They are in many places at once. They only appear
localized in one centralized space when we observe them. The most abstract example would state that even though when
we view the moon in the sky it appears to be in one place. However when we look away, it disperses and spreads out
through space and time.
3) Mind DOES affect matter. As experiments with particle slits and particle guns have demonstrated that particles
are indeed influenced alone by being observed.
There is not enough space to give Quantum mechanics justice in this blog alone. As there are many others who can
better explain its implications. One particular resource the is useful is the DVD movie What the Bleep do we know?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FpCSk7WC4GI
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3QlZ5O8_bGk&mode=related&search=
http://www.amazon.com/What-Bleep-QUANTUM-Three-Disc-Special/dp/B000FKO3JO/ref=pd_bbs_2/002-3953619-3472001?ie=UTF8&s
=dvd&qid=1189370337&sr=8-2
http://www.whatthebleep.com/
How this is all relevant to Astrology. For the first time in the scientific community the possibility exist that we
live outside of ourselves. Implying Astrology can be valid. Since the principal of Astrology, first must be accepted
that we are connected outside of the universe beyond our physical body. As if that cannot be accepted, then there
can be no acceptance of astrology.
The belief that we are connected outside of ourselves may manifest in many ways. A belief in god, Allah, the Tao, or
simply a belief that there is something out there other than ourselves. However, not a strict aetheism. As science
have taken the tonality of aesthetism. As it has questioned Gods laws itself.
And they Quantum Mechanics theory of entangelement. Helps to support that bodies in space which have no physical
connection may resonate in unison. Just as Astrologers have theorized we resonate in unison with the motion of the
planets.
However, the area of quantum mechanics that challenges astrology is the notion that is confirmed that the MIND DOES
AFFECT MATTER.
Therefore, our belief or expectations of certain transits working out or not working out. Effect the outcome. Our
belief of what we believe to be part of our character as a Scorpio or Libra, do affect what we get in life.
What instigated this thinking was one of the most popular movies today known as 'The Secret'. Which links old ideas
of NLP, the Law of Attraction, Positive thinking to newer ideas of Quantum Physics. That based on belief we attract
particular circumstances. More on 'The Secret' can be found at the following :
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_b1GKGWJbE8
http://www.amazon.com/Secret-Extended-Rhonda-Byrne/dp/B000K8LV1O/ref=pd_bbs_sr_1/002-3953619-3472001?ie=UTF8&s=dvd&q
id=1189371908&sr=8-1
http://www.thesecret.tv/
However, often what is implied by most Astrologers, as that the very EXPECTATION and thought of anticipation of
events can create the reality in itself.
Now I state 'implied' since modern day humanistic astrology may or may not (Depending on who you are talking to)
integrated ideas of free will and how they affect results in Astrology.
But traditional astrologers of the Ancient times we're much more fatalistic in their views and predictions. Viewing
life as fixed and created before. And this was influenced by a fatalistic society. Which attributed all to Gods
Will. However, this is a general stereotype, since throughout history, Religions have switched their opinion or
stance on Free Will or altering reality based on choice.
So it is not a question of Astrology alone, but a discussion throughout mankind that has existed how much freewill
do we have?
As looking at things from the mechanical universe. One can explain that we're emotional beings, which actually have
physical properties and hormonally releases. And that we are a complex network of neurons and synpases firing. In
response to stimuli. Therefore although we APPEAR to have a free will. We are in fact on autopilot without even
knowing it. Responding to our environment in a mechanical way. Answering our hungers and drives. Just as an animal
does by eating when he/she is hungry. Or mating when he/she desires and can find a obligiing mate. The difference in
humans is that we are intelligent to be aware and observe our own mechanical process of responding in life.
So therefore life itself COULD be fated since we're operating on autopilot. As one author rote in relation to
prediction :
PLACE QUOTE HERE from Quantum Book

But Theories of Quantum physics shows that we do not live in the strict mechanical universe. As the best broken down
example is the double Slit Theory. A better representation of it can be presented in the following link :
What the Bleep do we Know - Double Slit
Experiment